The Increasing Importance of Social and Cultural Awareness in Healthcare
March 23, 2016
by Kelsey Chong
The Revised MCAT 2015
After grueling undergraduate years of maintaining a high GPA in science classes, applying to competitive research positions, and procuring work experience in the medical field, it's finally time for pre-med students to put all their knowledge to the ultimate test - the MCAT.
According to the Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC), the Medical College Admission Test (MCAT) is a standardized, multiple-choice examination created for the purpose of evaluating students' problem solving and critical thinking skills, while also measuring the mastery of science concepts and principles in relation to the study of medicine . In addition to factors like GPA, medical work experience, and letters of Recommendation, MCAT scores play an extremely large role in medical school admissions in the United States, Canada, and Australia.
However, in spring 2015, the MCAT underwent its most extensive revision yet. Along with some format adjustments, MCAT 2015 is turning heads with its significant changes in examination material. In the new Social and Biological Foundations of Behavior section, the MCAT will now test on introductory psychology, neurology and sociology, with an emphasis on behavioral science. Similarly, the new Critical Analysis and Reasoning Skills section will replace the old Verbal Reasoning portion, and test exclusively on humanities and social science passages. In contrast to the memorization-heavy, natural science-intensive former version of the MCAT, the new MCAT intends to evaluate students' ability to apply knowledge of social sciences and adapt to real-life patient situations and behaviors. Given the long, 85-year history of the MCAT, this sudden major revamp begs the question - why the change?
Globalization and Growing Diversity
With the rapid globalization and technological advances of the 21st century, the world's nations have become deeply interconnected. The Internet and global trade provide us with constant exposure to foreign media, products, and ideas; modern transportation allows convenient travel and immigration between countries. As a result, nations like the United States are steadily becoming more and more diverse, boasting an abundance of cultures, identities, and socio-economic backgrounds.
The National Center for Cultural Competence describes cultural competency as a set of behaviors manifested at the organizational-level that allows those in the organization (e.g. a company, a group of workers) to work effectively in cross-cultural situation. It fundamentally relies on valuing diversity, having the capacity for cultural self-assessment, being conscious of cultural dynamics, having knowledge of cultures, and having developed adaptations to reflect an understanding of cultural diversity.
According to the Institution of Medicine, culturally incompetent care is directly connected to "poor patient outcomes, reduced patient compliance, and increased health disparities, regardless of the quality of services". On the other hand, culturally competent care is shown to not only improve care quality and patient satisfaction, but also job satisfaction and staff retention .
The First Stepping Stone
With the new emphasis on humanities in the MCAT 2015, medical education is taking a step in the right direction. Whereas the old MCAT left students unprepared for the gap between science and actual medical practice, the new exam encourages students to broaden their knowledge. According to Allan Joseph and Karan Chhabra, the new MCAT is sending the message to students that "they need [humanities] just as much as they need hard science, and the medical community now demands they have it".
The implications of this on the world outside of healthcare are immense. The MCAT's change signifies that cultural competency is becoming a mainstream requirement for organizations at large, including businesses, workplaces, and education systems.
Unfortunately, the new MCAT alone will likely not be enough to spark major change. In 1962, the MCAT actually went under a similar revision that expanded its "understanding modern society" section to test a wider range of general liberal arts subjects. However, in the following 1977 revision, criticism from medical school admissions led to the complete elimination of the general knowledge section, and the de-emphasis of cultural and social biases .
Despite the AAMC's efforts to emphasize a broader, liberal education, medical school admissions committees were still focused on the hard science achievements of applicants . Because the admissions committees directly determine who is admitted into medical school, they hold the ultimate power of declaring the current standards for becoming a doctor. Until medical school admissions change the application process to reward students' exposure to humanities, social sciences, and cultural differences, it's likely that any progress made will follow in the footsteps of the 1962 MCAT.
About the Author
Kelsey Chong is currently a second year at the University of California Berkeley, double majoring in Chinese and Japanese language with a Korean language minor. Aside from cross-cultural communications, she is interested in the intersection of humanities and other fields like business and healthcare. To connect with Kelsey, please email firstname.lastname@example.org.
1. Aamc. "Taking the MCAT® Exam." AAMC. N.p., n.d. Web. 4 Mar. 2016. .
2. Farmer, Juliet. "MCAT 2015: Changes to the Exam." The Student Doctor Network. N.p., 7 Mar. 2012. Web. 4 Mar. 2016. .
3. "Definitions of Cultural Competence." Curricula Enhancement Module Series. NCCC, n.d. Web. 11 Mar. 2016.
4. Lehman, Dawn, Paula Fenza, and Linda Hollinger-Smith. "Diversity & Cultural Competency in Health Care Settings." Mather Lifeways. N.p., n.d. Web. 4 Mar. 2016. .
5. Joseph, Allan, and Karan Chhabra. "For the New Doctors We Need, the New MCAT Isn't Enough." Forbes. Forbes, 22 Apr. 2015. Web. 4 Mar. 2016. .
6. McGaghie, William. "Assessing Readiness for Medical Education Evolution of the Medical College Admission Test." Journal of the American Medical Association 288.9 (2002): n. pag. Web. 4 Mar. 2016. .
From the Blog
Facebook, User Privacy, and Data Responsibility With great power comes great responsibility. Despite public outrage and Congressional hearings over the Cambridge Analytica scandal, Facebook's profits and user numbers continue to soar. Can Facebook strike a balance between transparency and responsibility around personal data? (more)
Targeted Ads: The Good, the Bad, the Unavoidable Targeted ads are meant to provide a better, more relevant experience for the user. Amidst a privacy scandal, Facebook is experiencing growing discontent from the public. How is our data used and is there a more balanced way to handle it? (more)
Jawbone: From Innovative to Insolvent Conventional wisdom says a startup lives or dies by its access to funding. By taking a look at Jawbone--which raised nearly $1 billion in funding before shuttering in 2011--this post explores the idea that perhaps what is even more useful to a startup than capital is collaboration. (more)